USB Microphone not quite working in PulseAudio

I recently bought a USB microphone. It's showing up in PulseAudio, and when I speak into it, it registers on the audio meter, but I can't actually hear the audio. PulseAudio is also showing the input for my microphone through the 3.5mm jack, which is unplugged.

Any help is appreciated!

EDIT: I can record it through SimpleScreenRecorder, so I know it works.